Disproven Facts
Biology

Traits are inherited through 'genes' on chromosomes, but the physical molecule of heredity is unknown.

Now we know:

DNA is the molecule of heredity. Watson and Crick described its double-helix structure in April 1953, but this discovery took years to reach K-12 curricula.

Disproven 1953

What changed?

Gregor Mendel published his laws of hereditary transmission in 1866, in the journal of a regional natural history society in Brno that few biologists ever read. For three decades, the work sat in near-total obscurity. When it was rediscovered simultaneously in 1900 by Hugo de Vries, Carl Correns, and Erich von Tschermak, biology acquired a framework for thinking about how traits pass from parents to offspring. What it lacked was any idea of what physical substance did the passing.

The chromosome theory of heredity, developed through Thomas Hunt Morgan's work with Drosophila fruit flies at Columbia University in the 1910s and 1920s, located the genes on chromosomes and produced detailed genetic linkage maps. Morgan won the Nobel Prize in 1933. By the 1940s, textbooks across the United States and Europe taught that inherited traits were carried on chromosomes. The question of which molecule inside the chromosome was responsible for heredity, which substance actually encoded the information, remained, to most biologists' surprise, genuinely unsettled.

The candidate that most geneticists favored was protein. Chromosomes contain both DNA and proteins, but proteins came in enormous structural variety, twenty amino acids assembled into chains of arbitrary length and sequence, producing a combinatorial space large enough to encode the information needed for heredity. DNA, by contrast, was composed of just four nucleotides, and many biologists believed, incorrectly, that these nucleotides repeated in simple, unvarying patterns. Something so monotonous, the argument ran, could not carry complex information.

That assumption was challenged in 1944. Oswald Avery, Colin MacLeod, and Maclyn McCarty, working at the Rockefeller Institute in New York, published a paper identifying the transforming principle in bacteria, the substance that could transfer heritable characteristics from one strain of pneumococcus to another. Through painstaking chemical extraction and purification, they showed that the transforming substance was deoxyribonucleic acid. Treating it with DNase destroyed the transformation; treating it with proteases did not. The molecule of heredity was DNA.

The paper was received cautiously. Avery himself was restrained in his claims. Many biologists found reasons to doubt the result, in part because the conclusion forced a reconsideration of DNA's structural possibilities. The debate was not fully resolved until Alfred Hershey and Martha Chase published their 1952 bacteriophage experiment, using radioactive labeling to show that when viruses infect bacteria, it is the DNA component that enters the host cell and directs the production of new virus particles, not the protein coat.

By then, the structural question had become urgent. Watson and Crick solved it in April 1953. Their model of the DNA double helix, two antiparallel strands wound together, bases paired by complementary hydrogen bonds, adenine to thymine and guanine to cytosine, had an immediate explanatory payoff that Crick noted in the paper itself: the specific base pairing immediately suggests a possible copying mechanism for the genetic material. If each strand could serve as a template for a complementary strand, the structure explained how genetic information replicated.

The 1953 paper ran to barely 900 words in Nature. Students graduating that spring had almost certainly never heard of it. High school biology teachers, trained in curricula that predated even the Avery paper, were still presenting genetics as a property of chromosomes without specifying the molecule. The implications of the double helix would take years to filter into classrooms. In many schools, the question of what carried hereditary information was still being answered in terms of chromosomes without a chemical name.

What Watson and Crick had done was close an argument that had run for nearly a decade, and, in doing so, convert the question of how heredity worked from one about chemistry to one about information.

A metallic scale model of the DNA double helix structure created by James Watson and Francis Crick in 1953, consisting of two intertwined spiral strands with connecting horizontal rungs representing base pairs.
The original DNA double helix model constructed by Watson and Crick in 1953, now on display at the National Science Museum in London. The physical model demonstrated how base pairing could explain the replication of hereditary information. · Alkivar - Public Domain

At a glance

Disproven
1953
Believed since
1940
Duration
13 years
Taught in schools
1945 – 1953

Sources

  1. [1] Molecular Structure of Nucleic Acids: A Structure for Deoxyribose Nucleic Acid - Watson, J.D. and Crick, F.H.C., 1953
  2. [2] Studies on the Chemical Nature of the Substance Inducing Transformation of Pneumococcal Types - Avery, O.T., MacLeod, C.M., and McCarty, M., 1944

See also

Biology
You were taught:

Heredity involves genes on chromosomes, but the details of how genetic information is used by cells are still being worked out.

Now we know:

The central dogma of molecular biology - DNA → RNA → protein - was proposed by Crick in 1957 and describes how genetic information flows in living cells. The genetic code was being deciphered through 1959–1961.

Disproven1953
Read more →
Biology
You were taught:

One gene controls one trait, and mapping the human genome would explain most diseases.

Now we know:

Most traits and diseases are polygenic—shaped by hundreds of genes interacting with each other and the environment. The 98% of the genome once dismissed as 'junk DNA' turned out to contain regulatory elements essential to gene expression.

Disproven2003
Read more →
Biology
You were taught:

Cloning an animal would produce an exact physical and behavioral duplicate of the original.

Now we know:

Cloning produces a genetic copy but not an identical individual. Epigenetics, developmental variation, and environment mean cloned animals differ from their genetic source in appearance, behavior, and health. Dolly the sheep (born July 1996, announced February 1997) was the first cloned mammal from an adult cell.

Disproven1997
Read more →
Biology
You were taught:

Biological sex is strictly binary: male or female, determined by XX or XY chromosomes.

Now we know:

Biological sex is a spectrum involving chromosomes, hormones, anatomy, and genetics. Intersex conditions occur in approximately 1.7% of births. The SRY gene is the primary determinant, but exceptions exist.

Disproven1993
Read more →