Disproven Facts
Geology

Oil companies have sufficient spill response capability to contain major marine oil spills quickly.

Now we know:

The Exxon Valdez spill (March 24, 1989) in Prince William Sound, Alaska released 11 million gallons of crude oil. Response was chaotic and insufficient. Over 1,300 miles of coastline were oiled and wildlife damage persisted for decades.

Disproven 1989

What changed?

Before March 1989, the dominant assumption in oil spill planning was that accidents could be managed. The petroleum industry’s contingency plans, submitted to regulators as a condition of operating in sensitive coastal waters, described response capabilities that, on paper, could contain and clean up a major spill within days. The Trans-Alaska Pipeline System carried crude from Prudhoe Bay on the North Slope to the tanker terminal at Valdez under a contingency plan that promised rapid containment. Booms, skimmers, and dispersant aircraft were on call.

In the early hours of March 24, 1989, the Exxon Valdez ran aground on Bligh Reef in Prince William Sound, tearing open its hull and releasing approximately 11 million US gallons, roughly 37,000 tonnes, of Prudhoe Bay crude into one of the most ecologically productive marine environments in North America. The response plan immediately encountered reality. The containment boom stockpiled at Valdez was understaffed and underequipped; the required response vessels were committed elsewhere. It took more than ten hours to begin boom deployment, by which time weather had deteriorated and the slick had spread beyond any realistic hope of containment.

The cleanup that followed was the most expensive in history to that point. Exxon eventually spent more than $2 billion on removal operations, employing 11,000 workers, 1,400 vessels, and 85 aircraft over four summers. The results were mixed at best. Steam cleaning of beaches proved to damage shoreline ecosystems more than the oil itself; estimates of how much oil was actually recovered varied enormously. Studies conducted years and decades later found persistent subsurface oil contamination in Prince William Sound beaches, and population effects on sea otters, harbor seals, and Pacific herring that lasted well into the 2000s.

The Oil Pollution Act of 1990, passed the following year, required double-hull construction for new oil tankers in US waters, imposed strict liability on spill responsible parties, and mandated dramatically upgraded federal response capacity. What the Exxon Valdez had demonstrated was not that major spills were inevitable but that the industry’s assurances about its ability to respond to them had been wrong, and that the regulatory framework had trusted those assurances without verifying them.

An aerial photograph showing oil cleanup operations around the Exxon Valdez in Prince William Sound, Alaska.
Aerial view of the Exxon Valdez oil spill response in Prince William Sound, Alaska, March 1989. The vessel released approximately 11 million gallons of crude oil into the surrounding waters. · NOAA - Public Domain

At a glance

Disproven
1989
Believed since
1970
Duration
19 years
Taught in schools
1970 – 1989

Sources

  1. [1] Exxon Valdez Oil Spill - NOAA Office of Response and Restoration, 1989
  2. [2] Summary of the Oil Pollution Act - US Environmental Protection Agency, 1990

See also

Drugs & Toxins
You were taught:

Industrial chemical waste is safely managed and does not pose long-term risks to communities.

Now we know:

Love Canal demonstrated that improperly stored chemical waste causes serious health damage to communities above and adjacent to dump sites. The Superfund program (CERCLA, 1980) was created directly in response.

Disproven1978
Read more →
Nutrition
You were taught:

Dietary fat is the primary cause of heart disease, and a healthy diet should be low in all fats.

Now we know:

Fat quality matters more than fat quantity. Unsaturated fats (olive oil, nuts, fish) are beneficial; trans fats are harmful; saturated fat's role is more nuanced than once believed. The low-fat movement inadvertently engineered a massive increase in refined carbohydrate and sugar consumption, contributing to rising obesity rates. The total fat restriction that governed federal dietary policy since 1977 was quietly removed in the 2015 Dietary Guidelines.

Disproven2015
Read more →
Geology
You were taught:

Corn ethanol and other first-generation biofuels are a clean, climate-friendly alternative to fossil fuels.

Now we know:

Life-cycle analysis found that corn ethanol produced comparable or greater greenhouse gas emissions than gasoline when land-use change was included. The biofuel mandate drove up global food prices and contributed to food insecurity in developing nations.

Disproven2008
Read more →
Medicine
You were taught:

The heart is a vital organ that cannot be transplanted - rejection by the immune system makes it impossible.

Now we know:

Heart transplantation is possible. Dr. Christiaan Barnard performed the first successful human heart transplant in Cape Town on December 3, 1967. Immunosuppressive drug advances made long-term survival achievable.

Disproven1967
Read more →